14 Non-Fantasy Halloween Romance Books You Must Read This Spooky Season
If you love the cozy vibes of fall, the thrill of Halloween, and the swoony tension of romance—but prefer your reads without witches, werewolves, or magical curses—then this one’s for you.
Non-fantasy Halloween romance books deliver all the autumn charm, pumpkin spice flirtation, and heart-racing chemistry without dipping into the supernatural. Whether it’s small-town love rekindled at a harvest festival, flirty fake dating at a Halloween party, or grumpy/sunshine vibes over cider and caramel apples, these stories keep things grounded while still giving you all the seasonal feels.
So grab your coziest blanket and get ready to fall for love—no magic required.
Her Favorite Jack-O-Lantern by Rebecca Rennick
When Jack Campbell moves back to his small New Hampshire hometown, the last thing he expects is to fall for the quirky neighbor with the black house and matching hearse.
Sally Smithson is perfectly content flying under the radar with her cats, her best friends, and her thriving design business—until Jack, her high school crush turned army veteran, moves in next door. Suddenly, avoiding town gossip gets a lot harder, especially when Jack makes it clear he’s more than interested.
Can Sally let go of her fears and trust that the man who once seemed out of reach might just be her perfect match?
Pumpkin Pounder by Laura Lovely
All Hallows’ Eve in New York City is when she thrives—and nothing gets her heart racing like a redhead with freckles and a smoldering accent.
Known for her love of gingers and her unapologetic confidence, she’s earned a cheeky nickname she’d never put on a resume. But when a tugboat Halloween party introduces her to the perfect Irish redhead, sparks fly and fantasies become reality.
She was only looking for one unforgettable night. But what if the man behind the mask is something more? And what if midnight doesn’t have to mean goodbye?
Pumpkin to Talk About by Allie Samberts
Mike Page thought he left Ironwood Flats behind for good—until a family emergency drags him back just in time for the town’s over-the-top Halloween festivities. Playing uncle was never in his plans, and neither was running into Belle Allen, the quirky librarian with a sharp memory and sharper wit.
Belle isn’t thrilled to see her high school nemesis walk into her bar. But between unexpected run-ins and undeniable chemistry, old grudges start to fade.
As the fall season sweeps in, so does something new between them. But with Mike’s return ticket looming, is this just a Halloween fling—or the start of something real?
Crazy, Sexy, Ghoulish by G.G. Andrew
Nora’s job at the local haunted house is all thrills and chills—until her middle school crush Brendan walks in. Now a horror-loving college cutie, he’s evaluating the attraction for a campus event, and Nora is desperate to keep her identity hidden behind fake blood and fishnets.
Brendan doesn’t recognize her, but he’s clearly intrigued. Nora just has to keep up the act until Halloween ends… and ignore how much she still likes him.
But the scariest thing this spooky season isn’t ghosts or gore—it’s the chance that falling for Brendan might mean revealing the real girl behind the mask.
Halloween at the Graff by Sinclair Jayne
Walker Wilder is starting over—new town, new job, and a Halloween event she’s determined to make a success. As the Graff Hotel’s new events director, she’s betting big on a ghost-hunting TV crew to bring in buzz. But she never expected the lead investigator to be a charming skeptic who rattles her far more than any ghost ever could.
Calum Quest is ready to leave the paranormal world behind. But one last investigation leads him to the spirited Walker, and suddenly the idea of sticking around doesn’t seem so scary. Especially when the sparks flying between them feel anything but dead.
Will a haunted hotel and Halloween magic be enough to conjure up a second chance at love?
Mr. October by Bethany Weaver
Sabrina’s used to being the favorite target of Grimsby’s annual Halloween prank war—but this October, she’s playing offense. And her sights are set on her best friend, fellow teacher, and local heartthrob: Luke, aka “Mr. October.”
What starts as harmless tricks quickly turns into flirty challenges and lingering glances that blur the lines of their long-standing friendship. With the small town watching—and scheming—Sabrina and Luke must decide if crossing into something more is worth the risk.
Filled with Halloween charm, sizzling tension, and small-town mischief, Mr. October is a friends-to-lovers treat perfect for fall.
All I Want for Halloween by Marie Harte
At a Halloween masquerade, Sadie is ready to forget her responsibilities and let her alter ego take over—just for one night. No names, no rules, no strings attached. Just freedom… and maybe a little fun.
Gear’s life is a mess, thanks to a scandalous breakup and a betrayal he never saw coming. But when he meets a mysterious woman in a devil costume, sparks fly—and for once, the night feels like his.
One unforgettable encounter leaves them both wanting more, but unmasking the truth might be harder than they expected. Can a chance connection survive the light of day?
In Her Pumpkin Patch by Alina Jacobs
He’s a grumpy billionaire. She’s a Halloween-obsessed hot mess with a hearse. What could go wrong?
Back in her spooky hometown after her big-city dreams crash and burn, Penny lands a temp job with Garrett, her brooding, pumpkin-hating boss. He’s moody, mysterious, and totally resistant to her fall-obsessed charm. But Penny’s not giving up—not on her haunted house roommates, not on Halloween, and definitely not on Garrett’s abs.
Her mission? Unleash some holiday spirit. His mission? Get rid of her. But between black cats, ghostly gossip, and irresistible tension, this October might just bring more treats than tricks.
Her Halloween Treat by Tiffany Reisz
She wanted a rebound. He wants forever.
When Joey escapes to her family’s secluded Oregon cabin after a disastrous breakup, she’s expecting solitude—not her now-grown childhood friend Chris, who’s all flannel, muscles, and sweet handyman charm. One look at him, and Joey’s thinking a no-strings fling might be just what she needs.
But Chris has other plans. Their chemistry may be off the charts, but he’s not about to let her treat their reunion like a quick Halloween hookup. He’s waited years for a second chance—and he’s not letting it slip away this time.
His Treat by Penelope Bloom
High school crush turned hot boss? That’s just cruel.
Emily’s got one foot out the door—Paris and her art dreams are calling. All she has to do is resist her brooding, off-limits boss until New Year’s. Easy… except said boss is the same cocky heartthrob she once adored (and maybe kind of wanted to throttle).
Now, they’re planning a Halloween party together, and things are getting dangerously flirty. One steamy slip-up won’t hurt, right? But when lingering looks and late-night sparks turn into something deeper, Emily’s left wondering—can she really walk away from the one guy who makes her want to stay?
Enchanting Eve by Darci Balogh
A cozy Halloween romance with a haunted twist—and two charming men who turn Eve’s quiet life upside down.
After losing her father, Eve finds comfort in their old house and her two sassy black cats. But loneliness is setting in fast—until Halloween season stirs up more than just memories. Her childhood crush is suddenly back in town, a handsome new teacher is settling into her dad’s old job, and her beloved home might be… haunted?
As Eve revives old traditions, strange signs and stronger feelings keep appearing. Caught between past and possibility, will she find love—and maybe a little magic—this Halloween?
The Bakeshop at Pumpkin and Spice by Donna Kauffman
A cozy Halloween treat filled with charm, sweetness, and a dash of enchantment.
In the picturesque town of Moonbright, Maine, fall means festive parades, flickering jack-o’-lanterns, and the warm scent of magic drifting from Bellaluna’s Bakeshop. Locals say the treats there come with a hint of love-spell magic—and three unsuspecting residents are about to find out just how true that might be.
As the Halloween spirit takes over and hearts start to flutter, costumes and cupcakes might just lead to connections no one saw coming. Because in Moonbright, love isn’t just in the air—it’s baked right in.
Pumpkin Everything by Beth Labonte
A second chance romance with small-town charm and plenty of pumpkin spice drama.
After a broken engagement and a brutal case of writer’s block, horror author Amy Fox isn’t exactly feeling festive. But when her grandfather crashes through a Dunkin’ Donuts—literally—she’s forced to return to Autumnboro, New Hampshire. Back in the hometown she swore off, Amy’s dealing with more than injured relatives and real estate decisions.
Enter Kit Parker: her childhood best friend, her first love, and the reason she left in the first place. As cozy fall vibes swirl and old feelings resurface, Amy must decide if facing the past might just lead to a sweeter future.
Love and Other Conspiracies by Mallory Marlowe
A cryptid podcaster and a skeptical producer go looking for Mothman… and find something even rarer: love.
Hallie Barrett needs a hit. Dumped by her ex and on the verge of unemployment, she finds unexpected inspiration in Hayden Hargrove, a charming conspiracy theorist best known for his Bigfoot deep dives. Hallie pitches a wild idea—his own web show—but there’s just one problem: Hayden is a disaster on camera.
So she jumps in to co-host, sparking banter, chemistry, and viral success.
As the duo chases aliens, monsters, and myths across the country, they just might uncover the biggest mystery of all—how to trust their hearts again.
